Sources and credibility
An editorial standard for traceable claims and honest corrections.
WORKING DRAFT · awaiting editorial approval
Working documentation — awaiting owner approval. Legal and operational texts are not final terms for a public service.
A citation should let the reader check a specific claim. Record the author or institution, title, known date, edition and page or archive reference. For online material, retain the exact link and access date; an institution’s homepage is usually insufficient.
Traceability, the credibility of a claim and permission to reproduce are separate questions. An approved bibliography entry does not guarantee every statement or permit hosting the whole document. Where only linking is permitted, readers receive a link and citation.
What supports the claim
A primary source is original evidence relevant to the research question, such as a contemporary plan or record. A scholarly study sets out methods and conclusions; an institutional report documents a particular institution’s position or activity. A secondary source interprets earlier material. Each requires attention to its origin and purpose.
Personal testimony records someone’s memory and experience. A hypothesis proposes an explanation; a disputed interpretation has documented alternatives. A historical legend is identified as a transmitted story, rather than a proven event. Explain these distinctions in the prose even when the source register uses a broader technical category.
Names, dates and disagreements
Retain original names with their language, period and source. Add a current name or transliteration separately without obscuring the original. Distinguish a document’s creation, the event described, image capture and publication. Do not expand a year or approximate period into an invented exact date.
When sources disagree, cite the relevant alternatives, consider their dependence on one another and explain both your conclusion and remaining uncertainty. Ten websites copying one mistaken account are not ten independent confirmations.
Images and publication corrections
Distinguish documentary photographs, historical reproductions, reconstructions and illustrative or generated imagery. Captions state provenance, dating and material alterations. For an article correction, record the reason and affected claim, save a new revision and submit it for renewed independent review. Restoring an older version creates another revision rather than deleting history.