← Research methodology

Verifying historical claims

Connect a specific claim to evidence and make the remaining uncertainty explicit.

WORKING DRAFT · awaiting editorial approval
Working documentation — awaiting owner approval. Legal and operational texts are not final terms for a public service.

Procedure

  1. Separate the text into checkable claims. For each, distinguish what the source directly shows or states from your interpretation.
  2. Examine the source's creator, creation date, purpose and intended audience. Record evidence that weakens the proposed explanation too.
  3. Seek independent material and check whether different accounts merely repeat one original statement. Attach a specific citation to the relevant part of the article.

Tools and equipment

  • A table of claims, supporting sources, conflicts and open questions.

Limitations and cautions

  • A primary source can be biased or mistaken. Matching online copies are not automatically independent corroboration.

Working with sources

Distinguish source class from claim certainty: primary, scientific, institutional or secondary source, testimony or unverified claim. Preserve hypothesis, disputed interpretation and legend labels in the text.

Search the archive